Category: History

Critical views on distorted or silenced past events.

  • The Moon and Time: The Sacred Feminine in Lunar Symbolism

    The Moon and Time: The Sacred Feminine in Lunar Symbolism


    The Ancient Connection Between Lunar Cycles and Femininity


    Moonlight has often been blamed for lunacy – that inexplicable condition whose very name derives from Latin luna (moon), directly linking frenzy to lunar influence. The Moon governs change, the things that shift, flow, and renew themselves without ever truly changing. What finer instrument for comprehending and ordering Time? What finer emblem of feminine nature?


    There was a time when the ancient inhabitants of this planet looked up at the night sky observing that something changed night by night and cyclically repeated itself. Thus, they began to become aware of a concept that was still embryonic and less atomically fragmented than today, yet meaningful and articulated: Time. Every night, that pale orb in the sky changed its appearance, shrinking its full sphere until it disappeared completely, leaving the dark night sky dominated only by the stars. Yet then it reappeared and, with the opposite change, night after night, it grew larger and fuller until it once again occupied its entire spherical shape. Its changing presence was the first clue to the perception of the passing of time. In fact, lunar reckoning became the first measure of time. Moon after moon, that is month after month, this celestial alternation was repeated, setting a well-defined temporal connotation and giving their union a broader framework in which to inscribe the dynamics of the succession of seasons. Though in rougher forms, accounting for time proved necessary for many reasons, not only to give meaning to change but also to the cycle of life and death. In 2007, an engraved ancient artifact was found near Rome, a simple pebble, which probably served to calculate time by scanning the lunar cycles. This archaeological find presumably goes back to a period between the Paleolithic and Bronze Ages and was created over time, demonstrating constant attention to the stars.

    Still, observation of the stars and natural phenomena gave rise to symbolic attributions that were not superstitious but rather hieratic: expressions of the profound connection that once united the sacred conception of nature with Mankind, who still lived in symbiosis with it. In the dawn of humanity it was therefore men and women themselves who were “divine”. In fact, in almost all primitive cultures natural manifestations are transformed into divine principles with human connotations. And so, every natural-divine element had a symbolic and inherent human connection. And vice versa. It is no coincidence that in many cultures, the Moon becomes the objective correlative of femininity, motherhood, and fertility.


    Editor’s note: For example, in Jyotish, the system of Vedic astrology, the Moon sign is considered even more important than the Sun sign—a striking difference from Western astrology, where the Sun typically takes center stage. In this tradition, a person’s emotional nature and destiny are interpreted primarily through the Moon’s position and its cycle, further highlighting the deep and ancient role of lunar symbolism in shaping our understanding of time and the self.


    Venus of Laussel (with crescent moon engraved with 13 notches on her right hand) and Venus of Lespugue
    Venus of Laussel (with crescent moon engraved with 13 notches on her right hand) and Venus of Lespugue

    In contrast, the traditionally masculine solar symbolism encompasses the characteristics of action, virility, and strength. Keeping with this correspondence, the length of the lunar cycle approximates the female hormonal cycle, which is also characterized by alternating phases; the male one, on the other hand, lasts 24 hours and has peaks and drops that figuratively follow the path of the Sun. It was easy, if not immediate, to grasp an astral similarity between women’s menstrual cycles and lunar cycles, associating the new moon with the bleeding phase and the full moon with fertility. Similarly, the waxing moon was seen as a symbol of female gestation and maturation, while the waning moon reflected their decline. The Moon’s rhythm- steady yet slow, ever changing yet dependable in its constant return- became the foundation of sacred calendars among ancient peoples, who saw in it not only symbolic and hierophanic meaning, but also astronomical significance, with Woman as its primary emblem in many cultures. Throughout Europe have been found small statuettes carved from stone, ivory, and bone: small Venuses with rounded, pregnant forms, which embodied both female, more specifically maternal, and lunar symbolism. The Venus of Laussel, carved in rock, represents a pregnant woman holding a crescent moon with thirteen notches engraved on it in her right hand, while her left hand points to her pregnant womb. All these symbolic details link the thirteen days of the waxing moon to pregnancy. The Venus of Lespugue, carved from mammoth ivory, also depicts a pregnant woman with ample breasts and wide hips and, like the first Venus, there are ten lines carved below her buttocks, corresponding to the moons of gestation. There are many others that depict the image of the Sacred Mother Goddess, a primal and generative principle. This is why female deities associated with the Moon, such as Diana, Isis, Hecate, Selene, Tanit, and Arianrhod, are associated with nighttime protection, fertility, childbirth, and the cycle of death and rebirth. For a long time, therefore, the Moon was humanity’s primary reference for visualizing and concretizing the perception of the passing of time, as linguistic roots also evidenced: from the Indo-European me- (“to measure”), which passed into Sanskrit as māmi, came the Latin mensis (month, moon) and finally the term menstruation[1].

    An illustration captioned “lunar stomach-ache”, from Jules Verne‘s novel Around the Moon drawn by Émile-Antoine Bayard and Alphonse de Neuville. It refers to a discussion on a “violent contraction of the lunar crust”:
    “A contraction! Something like a lunar stomach-ache.”

    Beyond its use as a temporal reference, which was later replaced by the solar calendar, for centuries the Moon remained a symbol of the sacred feminine, of what happens in the darkness and in the depths. Just like all the changes that are part of female nature. It also becomes a symbol of introspection, of the unconscious; a receptive principle like the feminine one and it is no coincidence that it also appears among the major arcana of tarot decks with the same meaning. Diaphanous, graceful, luminous, and surrounded by her shining handmaidens, the moonlike pallor is also a characteristic feature of female depictions in many cultures. Male skin, on the other hand, is amber-colored and kissed by the Sun.

    Not until later did the lunar reckoning begin to create difficulties. The lunar calendar, which was designed to mark sacred time, contrasted with solar calendars, which were more functional for civil and agricultural needs. The lack of reconciliation between the two systems made it difficult to calculate sowing times, as well as to organize civil time and work. While the lunar year, consisting of twelve full moons, had 354 days, the solar year had about ten more. A discrepancy that had to be corrected approximately every three years by adding an extra month to the lunar calendar, making the two systems align again. All the attempts made to reconcile the two systems faced the feeling of an imperfect time, out of sync with the stars and beyond human control. It was ultimately decided to adopt the solar calendar, and to retain the lunar calculation only for specific sacred and festive needs. That is how the perception of time must have changed. Gradually, Men felt the need to standardize and make everything calculable, including time. In Europe, it was Julius Caesar and then his nephew Augustus who applied the solar reform to the existing calendar, definitively switching from the Greek lunar calendar to the solar calendar of 365 days with months of 30 days instead of 29, alternating with months of 31. But the calendar we use today is from an even later period and can be attributed to Gregory XIII, who was also responsible for making it universal. The scanning of time thus becomes more incisive and clearer, and the Sun becomes the privileged indicator of its passing. Daytime hours, when the day was further divided into smaller units, became the time for activity and work; and night was only an interlude. The masculine and Christian principle of the Sun is contrasted by its decline. A time associated with darkness and evil, as well as witchcraft or sorcery.

    Aurignacian Lunar Calendar carved on the bone-tablet from Dordogne, France
    Aurignacian Lunar Calendar carved on the bone-tablet from Dordogne, France

    With the advent of hourly work and then industrialized work, the night ceased to be that sacred moment of introspection, dream, and intuition. It became instead a time of rest and waiting for the rebirth of the Sun. It is no coincidence then, that for thousands of years women have had no place in a world where even time holds a masculine declension that reflects all the traits of patriarchal societies. Time is an economically and quantitatively measurable unit, and not a unit that defines life itself. We could therefore aspire to recover and make our own that archaic and instinctive symbolism and renew that ancient bond with that introspective, emotional, intuitive, mysterious, and unknown nature which, instead of illuminating and enveloping everything as sunlight does, infuses only a pale glow that emphasizes both light and shadow and shows everything from a magical and different perspective.

    It is difficult to say whether in ancient times women occupied a position of privilege within communities. It is certain that there were many cultures and traditions in which this was the case, but it was not a widespread structure. However, the symbolic and sacred energy attributed to women has somehow survived to the present day, and we are now unwitting witnesses and heirs to those same characteristics. These should not be denied or replaced, nor should they be taken as an excuse to the subordinate and passive nature of women. An attribute that I would replace with the receptive/active dichotomy. The Moon, illuminated by the light of the Sun, does not produce its own light but reflects it, transforming it into a different glow, useful and necessary for observing reality from another perspective. Just as the Sun and Moon together define the rhythm of the days, so too do the masculine and feminine inhabit every individual, above their external traits, and both are essential for realizing the Unit.


    Frederick Stuart Church, The Witch's Daughter, 1881, watercolor, Smithsonian American Art Museum, Gift of John Gellatly, 1929.6.18
    Frederick Stuart Church, The Witch’s Daughter, 1881, watercolor, Smithsonian American Art Museum, Gift of John Gellatly, 1929.6.18

    [1] The associations linking women to the Moon and receptive power, and men to the Sun and active power, are not universal, rather belong in particular to a European tradition, although they are also found in other cultures.


  • Photographic Hermeneutics

    Photographic Hermeneutics

    A bridge for the interpretation of the past


    A Congolese man sits on the ground, contemplatively, in profile, gazing at two small objects only an arm’s length from his own body. An oblique triangular constellation comprises the man’s torso, his head, and then the focus of his vision: the two small objects, nearly the same shade as the man’s own complexion. Two objects violently, grotesquely come into focus as a foot and a hand—creating what Barthes calls the “studium”—or the aspect of the photo serving as a “kind of education” and recognition of the photographer’s (in this case, Alice Harris’) intentions: visual exposure of colonial carnage. The child is both physically present—in a gruesome synecdoche, if the hand and foot can possibly stand in for the whole body—and also absent, without even a name. It’s important to consider how this caption speaks—or doesn’t speak—to the image. The father is speechless—both in terms of being “dazed,” but also in terms of being denied any voice—or name—of his own in the text. Sontag elucidates how images, specifically those of nameless African victims, can perpetuate insidious narratives. She writes, “These sights carry a double message. They show a suffering that is outrageous, unjust, and should be repaired.” Yet, “they confirm that this is the type of thing which happens in that place.”
    Nora Nunn. “The Unbribable Witness: Image, Word, and Testimony of Crimes against Humanity in Mark Twain’s King Leopold’s Soliloquy (1905).” Genocide Studies and Prevention: An International Journal 12, no. 2 (2018): 84–106.


    Photography is as much a documentary tool as it is an evocative one. And when its two major qualities come together resulting in emblematic shots, photography acquires the ability to manipulate, orient or twist facts. It recalls past times and shows them, through the camera lens, in surprising and unexpected ways.

    On April 16, 1945, Margaret Bourke-White first captured the crematorium courtyard of the Buchenwald concentration camp near Weimar. The photo was published in the United States in Life Magazine in the following weeks. It was the first time that Europeans were confronted with the stark, naked horror of what was happening in silence and away from the stage of trench warfare. A single image, followed by many others, marked the moment when the realization emerged that the idolatrous image that the Nazi regime had built of itself through the widespread control of representation in photographs and films was being swept away by photographs capable of revealing the horror of the concentration camps. By showing and hiding, a society, or more macroscopically an era, sculpts the face with which it wants to be remembered. Indeed, images have the power to address a culture by evoking immediate feelings and influence the perception of reality. Today, photography surrounds us to such an extent that it becomes invisible while permeating every moment of our lives. When in 1826 Joseph Nicéphore Niépce made the first photograph titled View of the Window at Le Gras it was instead the first time that man could see reality as it was with something other than his own eyes. It was a prodigious invention that made photography a medium capable of objectively and forever immortalizing, or as long as paper allowed, a reality unmediated by the human gaze as painting, portraiture and landscape painting had been. In this way photography became a synchronically and trans-geographically usable fragment of reality, which meant that for the first time many people could have direct access to the exotic and to all those places described in books or stories. “To collect photographs is to collect the world” says Susan Sontag in her essay On photography. And indeed, even today, photography is what we do to take possession of a part of the world, in the manner of a souvenir, but in which we enclose essences, memories, sensations and truths. But its permanence gives it an additional quality, the diachronic one, which makes it both a fragment of space. A direct window into the near or distant past that allows us to look directly at an era to which we do not have access and interpret it with the eyes of the present making photography an artistic, documentary but also hermeneutic medium. Indeed, there are images that are not part of our culture or our time and photos that do not belong to both at the same time, so their reception will be alienating the greater the space that separates the audience and the eye behind the lens. Take, for example, the treatment suffered by Native Americans from the time they first came into contact with the new settlers until their ultimate confinement on reservations and how American institutions and public opinion have consistently downplayed the extent of the violence meted out to them, sometimes justifying and glorifying it through an unworthy representation of Native peoples. Photographs such as those taken in 1890 at Wounded Knee, however, bear witness to the actual massacres perpetrated not on handfuls of armed warriors but on old men, women, and children attempting to escape from the Pine Ridge reservation. The belligerent and violent portrayal of Native Americans in the westerns of Hollywood’s Golden Age-which, by the way, enshrined actors like John Wayne as a symbol of the American spirit and honor-was going to clash with the sight of dozens of piled-up bodies of Sioux clan members killed and ready to be buried in mass graves by the same American soldiers who had killed them. The power of photography lies in its immediacy and evocative power, therefore, photos can succeed where whole pages of exposé can do nothing. In 1973 Sacheen Littlefeather, a Native activist and actress, took the floor during the Oscars ceremony and after rejecting Marlon Brando’s Best Actor award on his behalf, she denounced American film portrayal and violence toward Native communities. She had eight pages of speech with her but could only deliver a small portion of it before she was attacked by John Wayne himself. If only she could have shown some images the effect on the audience would have been different.

    Despite the inherent ability to reproduce reality faithfully, each shot conceals an intent. For example, a photographic portrait can be a work of art or a forensic tool, as in the early photographic records introduced by the French police. The intent is less decisive in determining the reception and interpretation of the image than the identity of the observer. The photographer may, yes, imprint his or her personal gaze, but it will not stand in the way of a different reception. Although, therefore, photography presents itself as an objective, unbiased and realistic medium, it has the power to manipulate perceptions, direct feelings and twist facts. Giselle Freund, photographer and writer, tells how newspapers could twist the meaning of her shots in a matter of moments. All it took was to change a caption and a New York stockholder became a French stockholder, a simple reportage to the English slums is inserted into an American investigation to criticize the British crown by contrasting, side by side, the royal pomp and the squalor of the very poor industrial workers[1]. Proving how easily malleable photos and audiences are. Otherwise there are photos that appear to us as a glimpse of everyday life straight from another era. Images through which another time is recomposed in more detail. Specifically, at a time when oil portraits were gradually being replaced by photographic portraits-at first as an expression of the bourgeoisie but later extending to the aristocracy and all those who could afford a portrait-families or couples were being immortalized in the same fixed stillness typical of portraiture. A deathly stillness that harkens back to an unusual tradition, little known today but quite widespread especially in late 19th century Victorian England, of taking family photographs whose members posed alongside recently deceased family members. Photos of people, often children, some of them composed in funeral poses surrounded by flowers while others, dressed in their mortal best, were portrayed standing with the rest of the family with the aid of fixings. Images that are not part of our memory and that despite being an expression of a celebratory and commemorative type of family tradition give us another perspective from which to view the past and that recall the typical gothic, mournful and at the same time fascinating look that we attribute to that precise historical period.

    Beyond, then, the intent behind each photograph, its evocative capacity does not end in the fulfillment of its purpose nor, above all, in the frame of its time. Images of black slaves in cages triumphantly exhibited by their masters today reveal the brutalization and dehumanization of human life in slavery, while images of Asian and African workers in European colonies remind us that slavery in Europe did not end with its abolition but that in the colonies many were still its victims, albeit in different ways. A phenomenon also witnessed by the photographic documentation by missionaries in the Congo Free State documenting the brutalities committed and authorized under the colonial rule of King Leopold II showing boys and men mutilated as punishment for poor performance in harvesting the country’s main resources. This is why the role of photographs is not only instrumental and evocative but also, above all, hermeneutic. It alternatively constructs and modifies the way we see reality by orienting opinions and feelings. Indeed, it is no coincidence that in the 20th century photography was the most powerful medium used by totalitarianisms. This is why perhaps Giselle Freund considers the visual immediacy of photography not only its strength but also its greatest danger. Images become unintentionally symbolic of an era or event, especially when a shot bears witness to a debut or a record. So how can we not think with what excitement the first photos from space were seen, like Joseph Nicéphore Niépce’s view, allowed us to see for the first time, from a sidereal perspective, the place where we live? How many more times in the future will our own photographs seem so alienating and revealing in their depiction of an era that is no more?

    [1] Inquiry carried out on the occasion of the “Simpson Scandal” following which American indignation grew at not being, indirectly, deemed worthy of occupying aristocratic positions.

    [URIS id=3515]

  • Heretical fascination

    Heretical fascination

    Female participation and the sacred feminine in XII-XIII century Catharism

    In the Catholic Church the ministry was of course exclusively male. No such distinction was made among the Cathars. Women became perfectae, indeed were sometimes brought up with this specific purpose in mind, rather as Catholic children were sometimes vowed to the Church from an early age.

    Malcolm Barber, Women and Catharism, Reading Medieval Studies 4 (1977)

    From the Greek word καθαρός (katharos), meaning “pure” or Cathars as they came to be known in the period between the 11th and 15th centuries, were a religious group that spread throughout southeastern Europe and particularly in southern France, eastern Spain, north-central Italy, and the Rhineland. Despite the unshakeable stability and entrenchment of the Roman Catholic Church in Europe, Catharism was only one of the heterodoxies that found numerous followers. They were all indiscriminately branded as “heretics”. Being labeled a heretic was neither difficult nor rare; simply questioning the precepts proposed by the Church was enough to be considered one. Today heresy evokes above all the role of the witch, the embodiment of a female deviance that, in the 16th and 17th centuries, was at the center of inquisitorial repression and of a cultural construction charged with fear and misogyny linked in large part to the powerful work of demonization promoted by the Church. However, heretics were also all those who joined those creeds that opposed the corruption and secularity of the Church of Rome, its deficient pastoral activity and its departure from apostolic teachings. These groups were composed in a balanced way, and although women represented a massive component of the heterodoxies, they were certainly not the only one. Nonetheless, sin, subversion, seduction, and thus heresy, are attributes of Eve and of all women as her daughters, who are easily led astray by “devilish” ideas. On the other hand, as far as Catharism is concerned, female participation and the sacred feminine seem to be characterizing components also linked to the figure of Mary Magdalene who, held in the highest regard by the Cathars, would have justified even the highest regard of the female gender.

    Women, never welcomed by the [Catholic] Church, became Cathars knowing they could earn respect and actively participate in the faith. Needless to say, this mixture of women, virtue and apostolic poverty…did not sit well with Rome.

    Sean Martin, The Cathars: The Most Successful Heresy of the Middle Ages (2005)

    Catharism: The Dualist Religion

    The Cathar doctrine, which believes in the opposition between the evilness of matter and the absolute divinity and goodness of spirit, is ontologically dualist. The origin of the World, contrary to Christian dogma, sinks not in an act of divine goodness but in an act of diabolical evil. Matter and all its earthly declinations are the creation of Rex Mundi (Latin for “King of the World”), who, by seducing the angels, forced them into the cage of human carnality¹. From this fundamental principle derive the further cornerstones of the Cathar creed: the sin of the flesh, self-denial, the repudiation of sexuality and mating, and, linked to it, also the prohibition for the perfect (order of complete initiates and preachers) to eat meat, eggs and milk precisely because they are products of reproduction². So, unlike Christians, sexual intimacy was not only to be avoided in the absence of the procreative purpose or in adultery, but also in the marriage contract. This premise underscores the rigidity of Cathar belief and hints at an implicit negative judgment on the female capacity to generate life, as it contributes to the continuation of the cycle of metempsychosis. On the other hand, however, this same doctrine leaves room for what Anne Brenon refers to as “metaphysical egalitarianism”. In other words, if souls are indifferently good in their divine nature, those souls cannot be blamed for the body they inhabit. Cathar dualism, however, placed gender and sex on two distinct levels: while Cathar theory and practice advocated gender equality, sex was treated segregatively. Within the creed, therefore, women not only nurtured the ranks of the credentes (bonnes hommes and bonnes femmes, as the Cathars called each other), but could also be perfectae, a position that allowed for preaching and the officiating of rites. The most important of these was certainly the consolamentum, baptism by the laying on of hands, which was performed either on those who wished to be ordained perfect or on believers on their deathbeds as the only means of having their souls saved. As evidence of the authority of Cathar women, several names emerge in historical sources, including, for example, Esclarmonde de Foix³, whose Occitan name—formed from esclair for “light” and monde for “world”—means “light of the world.” She was, in every sense, one of the most outstanding women of her time. The daughter of the Count of Foix, she grew up in one of the regions of southern France where Catharism was most deeply rooted in the court culture of the local nobility, surrounded by troubadour poetry, the dynamic environment of the court, and influenced by the poetic and gentle image of women. She was initiated into the cult together with her brother Raymond-Roger and then at the age of fifty was consecrated perfect and, according to the chronicles, also archdeacon.

    Postacard depicting Esclarmonde de Foix
    Sculpture by Grégoire Calvet

    It is obvious that in the European social and religious landscape such roles were by no means common, and indeed, women in the Catholic Christian religion have always had a participation that-though active-was absolutely deferred and subordinate to that of men. Therefore, the role that women were empowered to play among the Cathars represented a characteristic perhaps not found elsewhere in Europe and which may have justified such great fascination. Gottfried Koch in his essay Women in Medieval Waldism and Catharism (1977) offers a sociological and Marxist view for which, since the Church in the Middle Ages was the most dominant form of expression, dissent and social subversion would therefore have been expressed, perforce, precisely in religion. And women, equated with an oppressed social class, would therefore have pandered to this need through participation in heterodox cults. These, however, are not the only sources worth considering. Indeed, there are many historical and statistical assessments that need to be added.

    The Historical Role and the Influenced Ideological Perception

    Richard Abels and Ellen Harrison’s study in The participation of women in Languedocian catharism (1979) offers a historical account of what the real role of women may have been, exploiting inquisitorial testimony and accounts of death sentences. Although the study does not deny a massive participation of women, very high especially among the ministers of the cult, it is the real possibilities and role of women that are scaled down. Indeed, what emerges is that although the religion did not by doctrine provide for the subordination of women, preaching, officiating rites, and hierarchical positions were largely entrusted to men more than to women. Confirming the statistical analyses is joined by one of the most important Cathar sources compiled by Raniero Sacconi, a member of the heretical group who later converted to the Dominican Order. In his treatise Summa contra Catharos (1250), Sacconi not only reports on the different declinations that the Cathar Church takes in the south of France and in Italy, pointing out the doctrinal differences between Cathars of Languedoc, Albigensians, Cathars of Carcassonne, Bagnolensians, and so on, but also reports regarding the duties and offices of the members of the creed.

    Expulsion_of_the_inhabitants_from_Carcassonne_1209_c
    Expulsion of the inhabitants from Carcassonne, 1209 (c. 1415).

    In this regard, unfortunately, besides confirming as we know that women were indeed an integral part of it, when describing access to the offices of deacon and bishop women are not directly mentioned. Furthermore, regarding the rites, Sacconi reports that the consolamentum could indeed be officiated by women, but he suggests that this was only done in the absence of perfect men. The additional textual sources used by Abels and Harrison, such as the roster of judgments issued by the Inquisition, reports that despite the high presence of perfectae, the testimonies documenting public preaching by them are remarkably few: only 12 times, despite 1,435 testimonies regarding perfectae⁴.

    229651_2x_ae781d0b-b60c-405a-9f2a-1c34987a8e6d
    Saint Dominic witnesses the miraculous expulsion of a foul, demonic black cat fleeing up the bell-rope. Terrified by the apparition, nine Cathar women renounce their heresy. A vivid example of medieval anti-Cathar imagery used to affirm Church authority and Dominican sanctity. Vincent of Beauvais, Le Miroir Historial (French translation of Jean de Vignay), Paris 1400-1410. Den Haag, Koninklijke Bibliotheek, 72 A 24, fol. 313v.

    One question cannot help but arise: if female participation among the Cathars was not as massive and authoritative as is popularly handed down, Where does this image come from? It is evident how the Christian image of women is so inextricably linked to the concept of sin that it greatly compromised the perception of any movement parallel to the Roman Church that was associated with female participation. Thus not only did ethical and theological reprobation prove detrimental to women’s lives and possibilities, but it cast a negative light on all those initiatives that did not suppress their nature instead. Thus, too, the not well-documented Cathars’ worship of the figure of Mary Magdalene and the theory that she may have been a concubine of Christ and by him begotten children, would be a theory probably only partly really related to the Cathars and originating in anti-heretical Christian writings, with the obvious aim of casting further discredit on the religious current. Indeed, there are no Cathar writings and testimonies confirming the cult of Mary Magdalene, who may instead have been held up by the perfects as an example of chastity after repentance. Still other sources claim that the symbolism of the cult of Isis, which developed in the region in the pre-Roman period, may have overlapped with the iconography and spiritual value of the Virgin and Mary Magdalene, but these seem to be poorly established sources. Unfortunately, the entire Cathar experience died out in violence. In 1208 Pope Innocent III launched the crusade against Occitan heretics, beginning a long season of violence that also affected French Christians and Christians, and only officially ended in 1229 but continued with the establishment of the Inquisition Tribunal. The destruction of the last Cathar stronghold, Montségur, occurred even later, in 1244.

    Albigensian_Crusade_1211_-_The_insult_to_prisoners_-_engraving_after_Albert_Maignan
    Albigensian Crusade (1211) – The insult to prisoners – engraving after Albert Maignan.

    The climate, which had already been unsafe since before the Crusade, went dark and forced the bonnes hommes and femmes to live in a more withdrawn way, moving cautiously from one town or city to another. Women, too, had attempted to move from place to place or to follow the withdrawn life of the woods which, not at all safe for a woman, went to cause a drastic decline in female participation of which, in fact, according to historical sources, the number of appearances, testimonies and preaching decreased. There is an additional social factor to take into account. The Occitan feudal nobility gradually became impoverished because of the equal division of wealth among all descendants, according to the pariage system, which did not exclude daughters. This situation persisted until women, in order to ease the burden on inheritance division, were increasingly directed toward religious life. In southern France, where the Cathar presence was considerable, many young women joined the maisons cathares out of convenience⁵. This suggests that the women who joined the creed were not only convinced believers or rebellious women seeking, as in Koch’s Marxist view, to express social dissent; nor were they only women claiming their sexual and social independence.Rather, the situation appears to be that of a community deeply influenced by religion, in which the members were not just convinced converts, but individuals formed within an established and culturally pervasive spiritual context.

    Unbekannt_-_The_Massacre_at_Beziers_1209_1890_-__MeisterDrucke-753804
    Massacre of Béziers, 1209. After the Cathars refused to surrender, Crusaders slaughtered the population — ‘Kill them all, and let God sort them out’, said Arnaud Amalric (1890 engraving).

    Final Considerations

    Drawing conclusions, female participation appears to have been not only a historically verifiable but also a defining component of Languedoc Catharism. Both modern interpretations and those coeval with the movement have ended up creating emphases: on the one hand, through modern sociological, media, and feminist readings; on the other, through symbolic and moral distortions proposed and disseminated by the Church. Depending on the lens one decides to use one can produce clear or distorted images. We can see women who in lucid rebellion and opposition to the medieval feminine norm find their social independence, or women who like men join an ideology in which they believe, not for the sake of actively opposing orthodoxy, but for the same reason that prompted many to join Christianity when it was not yet a world religion: the hope of salvation. The very instrumentalization of Mary Magdalene for her past as a prostitute whose role in the Cathar creed was, as for Catholic Christians, the metaphorical and spiritual one of “Christ’s bride” and not his carnal concubine, suggests how the Church’s view of the heretical group helped to change its traits. What is certain is that, in both cases, the figure of women proves to be functional in a deformation of reality regardless of the real historical role they played.


    Bibliography:

    • Abels, Richard, and Ellen Harrison. “The Participation of Women in Languedocian Catharism.” Mediaeval Studies, vol. 41, Jan. 1979, pp. 215-251, [https://doi.org/10.1484/j.ms.2.306245]   (https://doi.org/10.1484/j.ms.2.306245).
    • Barber, M. C. “Women and Catharism” Reading Medieval Studies, vol. III, 1977, pp. 45-62, centaur.reading.ac.uk/84350/.
    • Baring, Anne. “Esclarmonde de Foix Cathar Parfaite.” Anne-Baring.com, 2015, www.anne-baring.com/anbar49_esclarmonde.html. Accessed July 16, 2025.
    • Beavis, Mary Ann. “The Cathar Mary Magdalene and the Sacred Feminine: Pop Culture Legend vs. Medieval Doctrine.” Journal of Religion and Popular Culture, vol. 24, no. 3, Jan. 1, 2012, pp. 419-431, [https://doi.org/10.3138/jrpc.24.3.419] (https://doi.org/10.3138/jrpc.24.3.419) Accessed July 5, 2019.
    • Bennett, Judith M., and Ruth Mazo Karras. The Oxford Handbook of Women and Gender in Medieval Europe. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2013.
    • Bueno, Irene. “Preferire l’Eresia? Donne Catare in Linguadoca Nel Primo Trecento.” Storia Delle Donne, vol. 2, 2006, pp. 243–266.
    • Elliott, Dyan. Proving Woman Female Spirituality and Inquisitional Culture in the Later Middle Ages. Princeton University Press, 2009.
    • Gattermayer, Elena Bonoldi. Il Processo Agli Ultimi Catari. Inquisitori, Confessori, Storie. Biblioteca di Cultura Medievale, 2011.
    • Merlo, Grado Giovanni. Eretici Ed Eresie Medievali. Bologna, Il Mulino, 1989.
    • Walter Leggett Wakefield, and Austin P Evans. Heresies of the High Middle Ages. New York London Columbia University Press, 1991.

  • Witches Under a Spell

    Witches Under a Spell

    Witchcraft, Patriarchy and The Suppression of Female Wisdom and Independence

    In the collective imagination, the witch has always represented a liminal figure, simultaneously a healer and poisoner, a woman who holds knowledge and knows how to use it for both good and evil. The witch embodies one of the most controversial archetypes ever, living on the margins and refusing to conform to common rules. Her behavior is outside the norm, and the surrounding society seems almost irrelevant in shaping her identity. Her knowledge is passed down from woman to woman, and in her daily life, there is no room for the masculine: whether it be a husband or a god, the witch answers to no one but herself. The archetype of the witch fully embodies her independence, her power, the chaos surrounding her, reestablishing a new order-and it is precisely for this reason that she becomes seen as dangerous, someone to be controlled, and in the most extreme cases, suppressed. It is in this climate of terror that the real hunt to flush out women deemed witches begins, a process based on distrust, suspicion, aimed at controlling them and rendering them harmless. Fire takes on the connotation of the greatest ally for the inquisitors who burn witches at the stake until they are reduced to ashes, nothing must remain of them. That of burning at the stake is a strategy of control, autonomous and influential women must be repressed, they cannot and must not show the world their power, they must not show that a woman can be, exist and endure even without the support of a man. And so the term “witch” also takes on a new meaning, it becomes a label to silence, to delegitimize, if society sees you as such you are not worthy to be a part of it and have no right to speak. Today witchcraft has taken on a completely different character from what it was, mainstream culture often proposes protagonists with magical powers in novels, movies, TV series and music but it does so under a new and ambiguous perspective.

    While this figure returns as redeemed from her frightening appearance, she does so in a “domesticated” version, placed in narrative frames that present her as a victim seeking redemption, thus neutralizing the pure power she once represented.

    Scarlet Witch (Marvel Studios, 2021)

    The modern witch is most often moved by trauma or grief, as for example in the case of Wanda Maximoff, the protagonist of the Marvel TV series. Scarlett Witch is one of the most complex representations of modern witchcraft, her magic is born of loss, of missed motherhood, and her power is expressed to its fullest only in solitude, when she is sure she can do no harm. Wanda Maximoff claims her identity but does so in an isolated space and even when she seems to be close to emancipation this happens on a limited and narrow path. In contrast to the victim image we find Agatha Harkness, the antagonist of Scarlett Witch. Unlike the latter she is not the product of pain, she is not the child of trauma but, on the contrary, she is aware of her knowledge and claims it. Yet the narrative punishes her and confines her to the imposed role of an average, powerless woman. Once again the woman who expresses all her freedom and extreme power is repressed, becomes an enemy to be feared and contained, reducing her to the stereotypical image that patriarchy has painted of the female model. If a woman does not suffer, weep, or justify her actions, she cannot and should not remain free. Exile seems to be the only solution for pop witches who, no matter how hard they try to reclaim their powers, are forced to self-confine in remote spaces, a forced marginalization that seems to be the only way to be themselves.

    Elphaba in Wicked (Universal Pictures, 2024)

    Elphaba, the protagonist of the musical Wicked, is a prime example. She is not a witch by descent, she is not a victim and it is not society that imposes the label on her: she is the one who chooses to become one, she is different and to impose herself as a witch is an act of resistance and affirmation of her identity. In Wicked we witness an apparent process of emancipation, the protagonist’s choice completely disengages her from the corrupt patterns of society and allows her to be free but paying a very high price, that of exile. What pop culture presents us with is a figure who on the one hand reclaims identity, power, a privileged place on the stands from which to observe reality but on the other hand always does so through a glass, remaining separate and distant from her surroundings. Once again, the witch is distinct and separate, unable to integrate, and the only way she can survive is to keep her distance.

    Witch hunts are long over, yet the world seems not yet ready for them, and the feeling one gets from analyzing the role they take in contemporary culture is that of a sweetened and tamed version. There is no need to drive them out, to extirpate them because they themselves will be exiled or self-sabotaged anyway because their powers are too unwieldy to have a place among ordinary mortals. Even in the neo-pagan tradition and in the modern practice of witchcraft we see an “uncontrollable” representation of powerful women. Witch magic is presented to us as chaotic, irrational, and instinctive, as opposed to a methodical and rational reality associated with the male. Witches thus appear almost exotic figures, useful for the production of commercial and marketable content but never as instruments of true liberation. There is always something holding them back, something that pushes to keep them at bay and tame them. What transpires by analyzing the modern witch is a kind of illusion created by pop culture, an ‘emancipation by halves that consoles without transforming. And the witch thus translates into the great contradiction that women experience today: their strength is to be celebrated only if it is within the limits of what is controllable and harmless. Witches seem to be once again instrumentalized, no longer to terrorize but almost on the contrary to tranquilize, to make tangible that possible domestication of what might escape control. It is no longer others who are afraid of witches but witches themselves who are afraid of their own power.

    It is therefore worth asking: are we really facing the purest form of emancipation or is the witch a narrative domesticated by patriarchy?

    Anna Göldi, Europe’s last witch (P.Lo Giudice, 2008)