Tag: Maria Beatrice Quartu

Articles authored by or related to contributor Maria Beatrice Quartu.

  • Photographic Hermeneutics

    Photographic Hermeneutics

    A bridge for the interpretation of the past


    A Congolese man sits on the ground, contemplatively, in profile, gazing at two small objects only an arm’s length from his own body. An oblique triangular constellation comprises the man’s torso, his head, and then the focus of his vision: the two small objects, nearly the same shade as the man’s own complexion. Two objects violently, grotesquely come into focus as a foot and a hand—creating what Barthes calls the “studium”—or the aspect of the photo serving as a “kind of education” and recognition of the photographer’s (in this case, Alice Harris’) intentions: visual exposure of colonial carnage. The child is both physically present—in a gruesome synecdoche, if the hand and foot can possibly stand in for the whole body—and also absent, without even a name. It’s important to consider how this caption speaks—or doesn’t speak—to the image. The father is speechless—both in terms of being “dazed,” but also in terms of being denied any voice—or name—of his own in the text. Sontag elucidates how images, specifically those of nameless African victims, can perpetuate insidious narratives. She writes, “These sights carry a double message. They show a suffering that is outrageous, unjust, and should be repaired.” Yet, “they confirm that this is the type of thing which happens in that place.”
    Nora Nunn. “The Unbribable Witness: Image, Word, and Testimony of Crimes against Humanity in Mark Twain’s King Leopold’s Soliloquy (1905).” Genocide Studies and Prevention: An International Journal 12, no. 2 (2018): 84–106.


    Photography is as much a documentary tool as it is an evocative one. And when its two major qualities come together resulting in emblematic shots, photography acquires the ability to manipulate, orient or twist facts. It recalls past times and shows them, through the camera lens, in surprising and unexpected ways.

    On April 16, 1945, Margaret Bourke-White first captured the crematorium courtyard of the Buchenwald concentration camp near Weimar. The photo was published in the United States in Life Magazine in the following weeks. It was the first time that Europeans were confronted with the stark, naked horror of what was happening in silence and away from the stage of trench warfare. A single image, followed by many others, marked the moment when the realization emerged that the idolatrous image that the Nazi regime had built of itself through the widespread control of representation in photographs and films was being swept away by photographs capable of revealing the horror of the concentration camps. By showing and hiding, a society, or more macroscopically an era, sculpts the face with which it wants to be remembered. Indeed, images have the power to address a culture by evoking immediate feelings and influence the perception of reality. Today, photography surrounds us to such an extent that it becomes invisible while permeating every moment of our lives. When in 1826 Joseph Nicéphore Niépce made the first photograph titled View of the Window at Le Gras it was instead the first time that man could see reality as it was with something other than his own eyes. It was a prodigious invention that made photography a medium capable of objectively and forever immortalizing, or as long as paper allowed, a reality unmediated by the human gaze as painting, portraiture and landscape painting had been. In this way photography became a synchronically and trans-geographically usable fragment of reality, which meant that for the first time many people could have direct access to the exotic and to all those places described in books or stories. “To collect photographs is to collect the world” says Susan Sontag in her essay On photography. And indeed, even today, photography is what we do to take possession of a part of the world, in the manner of a souvenir, but in which we enclose essences, memories, sensations and truths. But its permanence gives it an additional quality, the diachronic one, which makes it both a fragment of space. A direct window into the near or distant past that allows us to look directly at an era to which we do not have access and interpret it with the eyes of the present making photography an artistic, documentary but also hermeneutic medium. Indeed, there are images that are not part of our culture or our time and photos that do not belong to both at the same time, so their reception will be alienating the greater the space that separates the audience and the eye behind the lens. Take, for example, the treatment suffered by Native Americans from the time they first came into contact with the new settlers until their ultimate confinement on reservations and how American institutions and public opinion have consistently downplayed the extent of the violence meted out to them, sometimes justifying and glorifying it through an unworthy representation of Native peoples. Photographs such as those taken in 1890 at Wounded Knee, however, bear witness to the actual massacres perpetrated not on handfuls of armed warriors but on old men, women, and children attempting to escape from the Pine Ridge reservation. The belligerent and violent portrayal of Native Americans in the westerns of Hollywood’s Golden Age-which, by the way, enshrined actors like John Wayne as a symbol of the American spirit and honor-was going to clash with the sight of dozens of piled-up bodies of Sioux clan members killed and ready to be buried in mass graves by the same American soldiers who had killed them. The power of photography lies in its immediacy and evocative power, therefore, photos can succeed where whole pages of exposé can do nothing. In 1973 Sacheen Littlefeather, a Native activist and actress, took the floor during the Oscars ceremony and after rejecting Marlon Brando’s Best Actor award on his behalf, she denounced American film portrayal and violence toward Native communities. She had eight pages of speech with her but could only deliver a small portion of it before she was attacked by John Wayne himself. If only she could have shown some images the effect on the audience would have been different.

    Despite the inherent ability to reproduce reality faithfully, each shot conceals an intent. For example, a photographic portrait can be a work of art or a forensic tool, as in the early photographic records introduced by the French police. The intent is less decisive in determining the reception and interpretation of the image than the identity of the observer. The photographer may, yes, imprint his or her personal gaze, but it will not stand in the way of a different reception. Although, therefore, photography presents itself as an objective, unbiased and realistic medium, it has the power to manipulate perceptions, direct feelings and twist facts. Giselle Freund, photographer and writer, tells how newspapers could twist the meaning of her shots in a matter of moments. All it took was to change a caption and a New York stockholder became a French stockholder, a simple reportage to the English slums is inserted into an American investigation to criticize the British crown by contrasting, side by side, the royal pomp and the squalor of the very poor industrial workers[1]. Proving how easily malleable photos and audiences are. Otherwise there are photos that appear to us as a glimpse of everyday life straight from another era. Images through which another time is recomposed in more detail. Specifically, at a time when oil portraits were gradually being replaced by photographic portraits-at first as an expression of the bourgeoisie but later extending to the aristocracy and all those who could afford a portrait-families or couples were being immortalized in the same fixed stillness typical of portraiture. A deathly stillness that harkens back to an unusual tradition, little known today but quite widespread especially in late 19th century Victorian England, of taking family photographs whose members posed alongside recently deceased family members. Photos of people, often children, some of them composed in funeral poses surrounded by flowers while others, dressed in their mortal best, were portrayed standing with the rest of the family with the aid of fixings. Images that are not part of our memory and that despite being an expression of a celebratory and commemorative type of family tradition give us another perspective from which to view the past and that recall the typical gothic, mournful and at the same time fascinating look that we attribute to that precise historical period.

    Beyond, then, the intent behind each photograph, its evocative capacity does not end in the fulfillment of its purpose nor, above all, in the frame of its time. Images of black slaves in cages triumphantly exhibited by their masters today reveal the brutalization and dehumanization of human life in slavery, while images of Asian and African workers in European colonies remind us that slavery in Europe did not end with its abolition but that in the colonies many were still its victims, albeit in different ways. A phenomenon also witnessed by the photographic documentation by missionaries in the Congo Free State documenting the brutalities committed and authorized under the colonial rule of King Leopold II showing boys and men mutilated as punishment for poor performance in harvesting the country’s main resources. This is why the role of photographs is not only instrumental and evocative but also, above all, hermeneutic. It alternatively constructs and modifies the way we see reality by orienting opinions and feelings. Indeed, it is no coincidence that in the 20th century photography was the most powerful medium used by totalitarianisms. This is why perhaps Giselle Freund considers the visual immediacy of photography not only its strength but also its greatest danger. Images become unintentionally symbolic of an era or event, especially when a shot bears witness to a debut or a record. So how can we not think with what excitement the first photos from space were seen, like Joseph Nicéphore Niépce’s view, allowed us to see for the first time, from a sidereal perspective, the place where we live? How many more times in the future will our own photographs seem so alienating and revealing in their depiction of an era that is no more?

    [1] Inquiry carried out on the occasion of the “Simpson Scandal” following which American indignation grew at not being, indirectly, deemed worthy of occupying aristocratic positions.

    [URIS id=3515]

  • Desensitization to the Surreal

    Desensitization to the Surreal

    Stillness in Normality and the Addiction to the Surreal



    I don’t think we did go blind, I think we are blind, Blind but seeing, Blind people who can see, but do not see.

    With this comment Jose Saramago perfectly describes the blindness, not so much clinical as emotional and human, that we adopt toward what we have around us. It seems impossible not to notice that although we are completely and omnidirectionally dropped into global daily realities, we are actually only passively and not actively participating in them. Immediate communication and media pervasiveness means that it is indeed difficult to remain unaware of current issues and events, unless purposely censored, but it is not obvious or absolutely consequential to receive in return a coherent response from the audience-society. In fact, a contrary attitude is almost more typical. It is a way of engaging the community and inviting them to knowledge rather than action, stemming from a modern phenomenon known as politaintment—an “entertainment show in which political issues are addressed.”[1]

    But it can actually mean much more than that, and so instead of talking about TV shows with a format of politics and entertainment, one can also go so far as to make politics the actual entertainment. For this, one can use, as above, the term audience-entertainment, which implies the transformation of the person into the viewer. Politainment was not specifically born in these years, however, it is obvious that through the rise and spread of various social platforms the latter has been greatly amplified. An extreme spectacularization of politics that from TV shows is increasingly infiltrating even the living everyday life. As already mentioned, it is evident that the mediatization, being pervasive, is not limited to politics, but also invests entertainment, cinema, business and every other sphere of society and interest.

    Why then despite the constant exposure to social issues and modern political and institutional personalities does there seem to be such a paradoxically keen disinterest in what is going on? Indeed, one might actually ask whether this is true disinterest or indeed habit, habituation or normalization of everything we see and hear. In the area of news reporting, both in print and in television news, there is a clear predominance of negative news, from changes in global balances to crime reporting. The constant exposure to violent images and content, in the face of far less visibility of positive news, ends up influencing the perception of reality and, to some extent, raising the threshold of tolerance for violence and negativity. It is obvious that negative news catalyzes more of the public’s attention even if these do not exhaust the realistic variety of what there is to report, but then again, television stations need an audience. The spectacularization of violence is based on a combination of emotional attraction, sensationalism, and disquiet, similar to the spectacularization of politics. Both find fertile ground in characteristics typical of the capitalist era, thus being all the more incisive in countries where the capitalist model is more deeply rooted. Concepts that in their media exaggeration come close to dystopian representations such as that of the Panem society of the Hunger Games. And so in the United States we will have personalities such as Franklin Delano Roosevelt[2], Ronald Regan, and most recently Donald Trump, all politicians who focused their political strategy around personhood and media prominence. It is no coincidence that Ronald came from an acting career while Donald, who also attempted prominence on the big screens, has always been known in the jet set. Reasons that surely ensured their political prominence.

    This use of provocation as a tool of power and spectacle was already present in ancient Rome. How must the Roman senators have felt when faced with Emperor Caligula’s mocking proposal to make his favorite horse, Incitatus, a senator and priest? The emperor’s character is traditionally known as despotic and impulsive, so even with the knowledge that the emperor’s provocation was intended only to ridicule the senators, one is hard to believe that any of them might have thought it would actually happen. Whether he did it or not is uncertain—since some sources state it as a fact and others do not—but today, as then, it would certainly seem provocatively absurd, paradoxical, surreal to us.

    So how else can we describe the candidacy of Kanye West, a well-known rapper of controversial fame, in the 2020 U.S. presidential election? It was neither absurd nor shocking, but surreal that such a celebrity could one day run for the American presidency. In itself, it would not even be something so inconceivable that from an artistic career one would turn to a political career; Arnold Schwarzenegger and Ronald Regan before him did the same. Between Incitatus and Kanye West, in addition to several centuries intervening, there is a fundamental difference namely that basically we are used to seeing a reality we were accustomed to disrupted or drastically changed, and each time it changes we become accustomed, more slowly or not, to this new version of events until it is disrupted again. We certainly live in a historical and technological context characterized by the dizzying and sudden progress so much so that we no longer have time to surprise ourselves, metabolize and live by new rules that we are already forced to change paradigm. A few years ago it was feared that artificial intelligences could become a tool for producing hard-to-find school and academic papers, with the real risk of undermining both the creativity of students and the evaluative ability of teachers. But almost suddenly more and more videos and posts began to circulate that were initially easily identifiable, but then gradually became more and more difficult to distinguish from a real product. A realness that has in itself the surreal not so much because of artistic content but precisely because the only thing that makes them recognizable, for now, is their adherence to a format they refer to and that captures attention. But assuming instead that there was a desire to create specially realistic content, at that point few would have the ability to grasp the fiction or even assume it.

    Citing other cases closer to us and tracing the same paradigm, one would have no trouble recalling Beppe Grillo‘s entry into politics after a long and successful career as a comedian similar in other respects to the path of Volodymyr Zelens’kyj, Ukrainian actor and president.

    Together, the spectacularization of politics and the personalization, produce a centralization of attention on the external and character personality of the politician and incentivize the dramatic-theatrical representation of politics. While indifference to politics was already evident more than half a century ago, today it manifests itself in the form of a disinterest masquerading as apparent participation. Yet, like every generation, ours continues to hold out some hope for the future. In this scenario, entertainment channels-including television channels-are based on the fleetingness and extemporaneousness of content, the relevance of which is often ephemeral. As a result, even relevant topics, when treated according to these logics, may gain media visibility, but rarely manage to retain their content value. Could this be the reason there appears to be little, if any, genuine reaction to what surrounds us? Almost as if most of the time we fail to grasp the magnitude of what is happening or are afraid to actually take a stand by continuing to live out our placid existences like those created by J.R.R. Tolkien, the Hobbits, so similar to today’s humans, holed up in their comfortable hovels dug out of the earth in which to shelter from world events. Modern man resembles Albert Camus’s Absurd Man who, instead of choosing Revolt, an act of affirmation of human dignity and acceptance to life, accepts conformity, that is, conforms to the evil of the world and the moral evil that man himself perpetrates either by applying it himself or by dissociating from it. Where revolt opposes all kinds of evil, conformism perpetrates the absurd [3]. Capitalism, individualism, anomie and nihilism are the characterizing elements of a social individual, reduced, however, to a spectator-consumer, renouncer in regard to moral values, meanings and rejection of the existence of any underlying reality and thus also renouncer of enacting “revolt” to preserve human dignity. This recalls of Hannah Arendt’s banality of evil, which recognizes in modern dehumanization and alienation, the basis for the birth of evil.

    A philosophical digression to show what is actually evident on a daily basis. And then in fact it is not only political issues that will create detachment and indifference, but all those other issues because they do not affect us directly. A level of alienation closely related to the individualism of many modern social structures as well as the modern feeling of estrangement accompanied by technological means. And here it is that when faced with news of wars still perpetrated against men, women and children, billion-dollar investments in tourist flights into space, sex scandals, court cases that become media we would have ephemeral indignations, we change channels or stations in order not to confront the evil that exists, in order not to feel that discomfort that causes us in an attempt to preserve the illusion of a happy life. In doing so, we avoid the collapse of an unrealistic worldview in which evil seems not to exist — or, even worse, we nurture indifference to anything that does not directly touch our personal sphere. The paradox of modern life lies in the fact that, even amid the constant mediatization of every event—from the everyday to the socio-political—even when presented in a dramatic or theatrical way, content disturbs us more for the reaction it provokes than for what it actually shows. Yet recognizing this does not mean one is not complicit, nor does it mean that no one remains capable of observing with a critical eye. What is general stands out more to the eye but there is always more, a less obvious minority in which to place hope.As absurd as it may sound, the fact that we have turned society into a spectator—rather than a protagonist—of political-institutional life, through media dominated by entertainment, immediacy, and superficiality, has likely fostered an increasingly homogenized reaction and a less conscious, more distorted perception of reality. What might once have seemed absurd when viewed from the outside now risks appearing normal, the result of a gradual habituation.


    Surreal can be understood as that which “exceeds, which goes beyond the dimension of sensible reality; which expresses or evokes the world of the unconscious, of the inner life, of dreams.”[1] It is a term we use very often, sometimes even inappropriately, complicit in the fact that there is certainly no shortage of occasions to employ it. If we were to include in the definition of ‘surreal’ also that which crosses the boundaries of reality as we experience it, then it becomes evident how quickly the surreal has become something concrete and tangible as quickly as the successive reversal of ontological positions. Reason why the perception of the surreal is only relative and depends on the degree of habituation to which we have arrived. Living in a society in which every area of interest is extremely mediatized, we are accustomed to seeing every issue presented on different channels: one institutional, one disengaged, comical, and one even more investigative or, if we wish, conspiratorial. How quickly, in fact, did we forget the surreal images of wild animals venturing through the streets of deserted cities during the lockdown? And how quickly did we forget the lockdown itself? It looked like a scene from any post-apocalyptic movie in which skyscrapers overgrown with ivy and other climbing plants provide a backdrop for an absent urban population replaced only by wildlife. Where, instead, will tourist trips to the skies and seas destined only for the wealthy come in? Not to mention that even in this case the image of Katy Perry in zero-gravity space (Ed. note: technically microgravity, not true zero-G), aboard a multibillion-dollar project to commercialize orbital flights all things considered, has not struggled to be surpassed. And yet, until recently, we had only seen something like this in cartoons like Futurama—hardly something so easy to forget. There was certainly no shortage of outrage and theories from those who thought it absurd that we had reached such a high level of progress that it is possible to travel as tourists in space, but at the same time no more lunar missions are planned. Just as much disbelief was raised by the voyage of the private submarine Titan, which ended in tragedy, despite its original goal of enabling visits to the wreck of the RMS Titanic—once again, a completely exclusive project. A project, again, absolutely exclusive. This time, in addition to a kind of vindictive satisfaction, other theories were raised about the absurdity of being part of a humanity that has made lunar expeditions but can do little against the deep sea. In short, a “conspiracy” legitimately driven by the incredulity and absurdity with which much news and situations reach us.

    Stockton Rush, CEO of OceanGate, demonstrating the Logitech F710 controller used to pilot the Titan submersible.
    A budget-friendly gamepad as the interface between deep-sea exploration and disaster—blurring the line between simulation and reality in a way that’s nothing short of surreal.

    Likewise, similar manifestations will surely appear in the future—a future we can hardly begin to imagine.. Over time we slowly adapt to what is happening around us, and the threshold of what we perceive as surreal tends to gradually rise. This makes us almost indifferent to any event today, and leaves open the question of how we might react in the future, when our sensitivity to the absurd has now been drastically thinned.

    So, today, with the awareness of the absurd, the stark confrontation with reality occupies little time because we immediately turn to humor and comedy to digest what would be too perturbing for our minds or would require us to raise more questions than we could and would like to answer. And so it all flows into the endless stream of doomscrolling, which offers us the comfortable privilege of ignoring—with a simple tap—whatever disturbs, upsets or simply doesn’t interest us. News of a new movie’s release may leave us indifferent—but what if, instead, it were news of a crime that had shocked the community? Or what if it were images of a critical humanitarian situation somewhere in the world? Or even just the news that would radically change the image of a public figure for the better or worse? In all these cases we have the ability to move on because all in all “it’s not that strange.” It almost seems as if most of the time we fail to grasp the magnitude of what is happening, and so we see flowing before us a surreal dreamlike manifestation with horrific traits that we have neither the means nor the will to curb and scale back. And here we are, in a society that, at its extreme, increasingly resembles a post-apocalyptic world, populated by surreal and almost paroxysmal characters. In this world, the streets of America’s metropolises appear populated by the living dead, as if they had arrived ahead of schedule; Nobel Peace Prize nominees are found entangled in matters of war, having done little to advance peace.

    Obama Win the Nobel Prize (2009)
    Barack Obama holding the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize medal.

    Here are billions of dollars being invested in technologies that will benefit only a wealthy few when the population is being asked to feel pity and humanitarian spirit toward the poor and needy fueling popular guilt and social disintegration; or here is the spectacularization of violence becoming a daily occurrence incentivized not only by television stations that often air uncensored images, but also by true crime-like reaction formats. There are few things that succeed in arousing outrage and concern that is not, however, ephemeral and quickly replaced by a sense of fatalistic resignation and helplessness, and certainly this real outrage cannot be manifested exclusively in the world of the airwaves. Perhaps the real interest and outrage is seen by participation in the streets at demonstrations and marches more than by the indignant and enraged reactions in comment sections. When there is a perception that something is really wrong, that it can significantly impair human dignity and that consideration is being taken away from us at that point the issue needs to be brought out into the world of reality. And that is perhaps the only way to realize the surreality and to turn it around so that we are not completely addicted to it.

    [1] Politainment – Nieland – Major Reference Works – Wiley Online Library

    [2] Notably, he delivered “fireside chats” — informal speeches through which he addressed the nation during times of national crisis.

    [3] For Camus, the absurd lies in the rational search for meaning and purpose in the world that collides with the irrationality of the world itself, and these concepts are expressed primarily in The Stranger (1942) and The Myth of Sisyphus (1942)

  • Heretical fascination

    Heretical fascination

    Female participation and the sacred feminine in XII-XIII century Catharism

    In the Catholic Church the ministry was of course exclusively male. No such distinction was made among the Cathars. Women became perfectae, indeed were sometimes brought up with this specific purpose in mind, rather as Catholic children were sometimes vowed to the Church from an early age.

    Malcolm Barber, Women and Catharism, Reading Medieval Studies 4 (1977)

    From the Greek word καθαρός (katharos), meaning “pure” or Cathars as they came to be known in the period between the 11th and 15th centuries, were a religious group that spread throughout southeastern Europe and particularly in southern France, eastern Spain, north-central Italy, and the Rhineland. Despite the unshakeable stability and entrenchment of the Roman Catholic Church in Europe, Catharism was only one of the heterodoxies that found numerous followers. They were all indiscriminately branded as “heretics”. Being labeled a heretic was neither difficult nor rare; simply questioning the precepts proposed by the Church was enough to be considered one. Today heresy evokes above all the role of the witch, the embodiment of a female deviance that, in the 16th and 17th centuries, was at the center of inquisitorial repression and of a cultural construction charged with fear and misogyny linked in large part to the powerful work of demonization promoted by the Church. However, heretics were also all those who joined those creeds that opposed the corruption and secularity of the Church of Rome, its deficient pastoral activity and its departure from apostolic teachings. These groups were composed in a balanced way, and although women represented a massive component of the heterodoxies, they were certainly not the only one. Nonetheless, sin, subversion, seduction, and thus heresy, are attributes of Eve and of all women as her daughters, who are easily led astray by “devilish” ideas. On the other hand, as far as Catharism is concerned, female participation and the sacred feminine seem to be characterizing components also linked to the figure of Mary Magdalene who, held in the highest regard by the Cathars, would have justified even the highest regard of the female gender.

    Women, never welcomed by the [Catholic] Church, became Cathars knowing they could earn respect and actively participate in the faith. Needless to say, this mixture of women, virtue and apostolic poverty…did not sit well with Rome.

    Sean Martin, The Cathars: The Most Successful Heresy of the Middle Ages (2005)

    Catharism: The Dualist Religion

    The Cathar doctrine, which believes in the opposition between the evilness of matter and the absolute divinity and goodness of spirit, is ontologically dualist. The origin of the World, contrary to Christian dogma, sinks not in an act of divine goodness but in an act of diabolical evil. Matter and all its earthly declinations are the creation of Rex Mundi (Latin for “King of the World”), who, by seducing the angels, forced them into the cage of human carnality¹. From this fundamental principle derive the further cornerstones of the Cathar creed: the sin of the flesh, self-denial, the repudiation of sexuality and mating, and, linked to it, also the prohibition for the perfect (order of complete initiates and preachers) to eat meat, eggs and milk precisely because they are products of reproduction². So, unlike Christians, sexual intimacy was not only to be avoided in the absence of the procreative purpose or in adultery, but also in the marriage contract. This premise underscores the rigidity of Cathar belief and hints at an implicit negative judgment on the female capacity to generate life, as it contributes to the continuation of the cycle of metempsychosis. On the other hand, however, this same doctrine leaves room for what Anne Brenon refers to as “metaphysical egalitarianism”. In other words, if souls are indifferently good in their divine nature, those souls cannot be blamed for the body they inhabit. Cathar dualism, however, placed gender and sex on two distinct levels: while Cathar theory and practice advocated gender equality, sex was treated segregatively. Within the creed, therefore, women not only nurtured the ranks of the credentes (bonnes hommes and bonnes femmes, as the Cathars called each other), but could also be perfectae, a position that allowed for preaching and the officiating of rites. The most important of these was certainly the consolamentum, baptism by the laying on of hands, which was performed either on those who wished to be ordained perfect or on believers on their deathbeds as the only means of having their souls saved. As evidence of the authority of Cathar women, several names emerge in historical sources, including, for example, Esclarmonde de Foix³, whose Occitan name—formed from esclair for “light” and monde for “world”—means “light of the world.” She was, in every sense, one of the most outstanding women of her time. The daughter of the Count of Foix, she grew up in one of the regions of southern France where Catharism was most deeply rooted in the court culture of the local nobility, surrounded by troubadour poetry, the dynamic environment of the court, and influenced by the poetic and gentle image of women. She was initiated into the cult together with her brother Raymond-Roger and then at the age of fifty was consecrated perfect and, according to the chronicles, also archdeacon.

    Postacard depicting Esclarmonde de Foix
    Sculpture by Grégoire Calvet

    It is obvious that in the European social and religious landscape such roles were by no means common, and indeed, women in the Catholic Christian religion have always had a participation that-though active-was absolutely deferred and subordinate to that of men. Therefore, the role that women were empowered to play among the Cathars represented a characteristic perhaps not found elsewhere in Europe and which may have justified such great fascination. Gottfried Koch in his essay Women in Medieval Waldism and Catharism (1977) offers a sociological and Marxist view for which, since the Church in the Middle Ages was the most dominant form of expression, dissent and social subversion would therefore have been expressed, perforce, precisely in religion. And women, equated with an oppressed social class, would therefore have pandered to this need through participation in heterodox cults. These, however, are not the only sources worth considering. Indeed, there are many historical and statistical assessments that need to be added.

    The Historical Role and the Influenced Ideological Perception

    Richard Abels and Ellen Harrison’s study in The participation of women in Languedocian catharism (1979) offers a historical account of what the real role of women may have been, exploiting inquisitorial testimony and accounts of death sentences. Although the study does not deny a massive participation of women, very high especially among the ministers of the cult, it is the real possibilities and role of women that are scaled down. Indeed, what emerges is that although the religion did not by doctrine provide for the subordination of women, preaching, officiating rites, and hierarchical positions were largely entrusted to men more than to women. Confirming the statistical analyses is joined by one of the most important Cathar sources compiled by Raniero Sacconi, a member of the heretical group who later converted to the Dominican Order. In his treatise Summa contra Catharos (1250), Sacconi not only reports on the different declinations that the Cathar Church takes in the south of France and in Italy, pointing out the doctrinal differences between Cathars of Languedoc, Albigensians, Cathars of Carcassonne, Bagnolensians, and so on, but also reports regarding the duties and offices of the members of the creed.

    Expulsion_of_the_inhabitants_from_Carcassonne_1209_c
    Expulsion of the inhabitants from Carcassonne, 1209 (c. 1415).

    In this regard, unfortunately, besides confirming as we know that women were indeed an integral part of it, when describing access to the offices of deacon and bishop women are not directly mentioned. Furthermore, regarding the rites, Sacconi reports that the consolamentum could indeed be officiated by women, but he suggests that this was only done in the absence of perfect men. The additional textual sources used by Abels and Harrison, such as the roster of judgments issued by the Inquisition, reports that despite the high presence of perfectae, the testimonies documenting public preaching by them are remarkably few: only 12 times, despite 1,435 testimonies regarding perfectae⁴.

    229651_2x_ae781d0b-b60c-405a-9f2a-1c34987a8e6d
    Saint Dominic witnesses the miraculous expulsion of a foul, demonic black cat fleeing up the bell-rope. Terrified by the apparition, nine Cathar women renounce their heresy. A vivid example of medieval anti-Cathar imagery used to affirm Church authority and Dominican sanctity. Vincent of Beauvais, Le Miroir Historial (French translation of Jean de Vignay), Paris 1400-1410. Den Haag, Koninklijke Bibliotheek, 72 A 24, fol. 313v.

    One question cannot help but arise: if female participation among the Cathars was not as massive and authoritative as is popularly handed down, Where does this image come from? It is evident how the Christian image of women is so inextricably linked to the concept of sin that it greatly compromised the perception of any movement parallel to the Roman Church that was associated with female participation. Thus not only did ethical and theological reprobation prove detrimental to women’s lives and possibilities, but it cast a negative light on all those initiatives that did not suppress their nature instead. Thus, too, the not well-documented Cathars’ worship of the figure of Mary Magdalene and the theory that she may have been a concubine of Christ and by him begotten children, would be a theory probably only partly really related to the Cathars and originating in anti-heretical Christian writings, with the obvious aim of casting further discredit on the religious current. Indeed, there are no Cathar writings and testimonies confirming the cult of Mary Magdalene, who may instead have been held up by the perfects as an example of chastity after repentance. Still other sources claim that the symbolism of the cult of Isis, which developed in the region in the pre-Roman period, may have overlapped with the iconography and spiritual value of the Virgin and Mary Magdalene, but these seem to be poorly established sources. Unfortunately, the entire Cathar experience died out in violence. In 1208 Pope Innocent III launched the crusade against Occitan heretics, beginning a long season of violence that also affected French Christians and Christians, and only officially ended in 1229 but continued with the establishment of the Inquisition Tribunal. The destruction of the last Cathar stronghold, Montségur, occurred even later, in 1244.

    Albigensian_Crusade_1211_-_The_insult_to_prisoners_-_engraving_after_Albert_Maignan
    Albigensian Crusade (1211) – The insult to prisoners – engraving after Albert Maignan.

    The climate, which had already been unsafe since before the Crusade, went dark and forced the bonnes hommes and femmes to live in a more withdrawn way, moving cautiously from one town or city to another. Women, too, had attempted to move from place to place or to follow the withdrawn life of the woods which, not at all safe for a woman, went to cause a drastic decline in female participation of which, in fact, according to historical sources, the number of appearances, testimonies and preaching decreased. There is an additional social factor to take into account. The Occitan feudal nobility gradually became impoverished because of the equal division of wealth among all descendants, according to the pariage system, which did not exclude daughters. This situation persisted until women, in order to ease the burden on inheritance division, were increasingly directed toward religious life. In southern France, where the Cathar presence was considerable, many young women joined the maisons cathares out of convenience⁵. This suggests that the women who joined the creed were not only convinced believers or rebellious women seeking, as in Koch’s Marxist view, to express social dissent; nor were they only women claiming their sexual and social independence.Rather, the situation appears to be that of a community deeply influenced by religion, in which the members were not just convinced converts, but individuals formed within an established and culturally pervasive spiritual context.

    Unbekannt_-_The_Massacre_at_Beziers_1209_1890_-__MeisterDrucke-753804
    Massacre of Béziers, 1209. After the Cathars refused to surrender, Crusaders slaughtered the population — ‘Kill them all, and let God sort them out’, said Arnaud Amalric (1890 engraving).

    Final Considerations

    Drawing conclusions, female participation appears to have been not only a historically verifiable but also a defining component of Languedoc Catharism. Both modern interpretations and those coeval with the movement have ended up creating emphases: on the one hand, through modern sociological, media, and feminist readings; on the other, through symbolic and moral distortions proposed and disseminated by the Church. Depending on the lens one decides to use one can produce clear or distorted images. We can see women who in lucid rebellion and opposition to the medieval feminine norm find their social independence, or women who like men join an ideology in which they believe, not for the sake of actively opposing orthodoxy, but for the same reason that prompted many to join Christianity when it was not yet a world religion: the hope of salvation. The very instrumentalization of Mary Magdalene for her past as a prostitute whose role in the Cathar creed was, as for Catholic Christians, the metaphorical and spiritual one of “Christ’s bride” and not his carnal concubine, suggests how the Church’s view of the heretical group helped to change its traits. What is certain is that, in both cases, the figure of women proves to be functional in a deformation of reality regardless of the real historical role they played.


    Bibliography:

    • Abels, Richard, and Ellen Harrison. “The Participation of Women in Languedocian Catharism.” Mediaeval Studies, vol. 41, Jan. 1979, pp. 215-251, [https://doi.org/10.1484/j.ms.2.306245]   (https://doi.org/10.1484/j.ms.2.306245).
    • Barber, M. C. “Women and Catharism” Reading Medieval Studies, vol. III, 1977, pp. 45-62, centaur.reading.ac.uk/84350/.
    • Baring, Anne. “Esclarmonde de Foix Cathar Parfaite.” Anne-Baring.com, 2015, www.anne-baring.com/anbar49_esclarmonde.html. Accessed July 16, 2025.
    • Beavis, Mary Ann. “The Cathar Mary Magdalene and the Sacred Feminine: Pop Culture Legend vs. Medieval Doctrine.” Journal of Religion and Popular Culture, vol. 24, no. 3, Jan. 1, 2012, pp. 419-431, [https://doi.org/10.3138/jrpc.24.3.419] (https://doi.org/10.3138/jrpc.24.3.419) Accessed July 5, 2019.
    • Bennett, Judith M., and Ruth Mazo Karras. The Oxford Handbook of Women and Gender in Medieval Europe. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2013.
    • Bueno, Irene. “Preferire l’Eresia? Donne Catare in Linguadoca Nel Primo Trecento.” Storia Delle Donne, vol. 2, 2006, pp. 243–266.
    • Elliott, Dyan. Proving Woman Female Spirituality and Inquisitional Culture in the Later Middle Ages. Princeton University Press, 2009.
    • Gattermayer, Elena Bonoldi. Il Processo Agli Ultimi Catari. Inquisitori, Confessori, Storie. Biblioteca di Cultura Medievale, 2011.
    • Merlo, Grado Giovanni. Eretici Ed Eresie Medievali. Bologna, Il Mulino, 1989.
    • Walter Leggett Wakefield, and Austin P Evans. Heresies of the High Middle Ages. New York London Columbia University Press, 1991.